
LOS ANGELES, Calif. -- [Editor's note: This is an adapted version that corrects the name of the producer of Marketplace.]
In a big year for green initiatives, it's inevitable that there will be some big greenwashes as well; and as part of an onslaught of year's-end lists, the Greenwash Brigade on American Public Media's Marketplace has tallied their list of the most notable green flops of 2008.
Although the list is unranked, perhaps it is unsurprising that Fiji Water takes the first slot for its green campaign. Although the company's efforts to disclose emissions impacts and supply chain footprint are key steps to greening any product, the Greenwash Brigade takes them to task by writing, "Yes, shipping water in container ships from a pristine aquifer in paradise is somehow green."
On a much larger scale, the Brigade also calls out the Clean Coal movement, labeling it "the ultimate oxymoron." Although the coal industry has been highlighting its investments in carbon capture and sequestration technologies, here's how the Greenwash Brigade sums up the state of the art: "Burning coal is the leading source of global warming emissions. Burning coal isn’t clean. Mountain top removal isn’t clean. Carbon Capture and Sequestration is a pipe dream at this point. And the 2008 presidential candidates fell for it."
Speaking of the presidential race, despite plans from both parties to green their conventions this year, the projects make the greenwash list for being leaps and bounds beyond any actual policies either party has undertaken to address a host of environmental issues.
Notable inclusions on the list are Apple Computer, BP, and the Detroit auto industry -- GM makes this list twice this year. Read the full list at PublicRadio.org, and weigh in with your own top greenwashes below.
Many Beverage Companies Are Getting Failing Grades
Unfortunately it is not just Fiji Water that is guilty of green washing. The entire single-serve beverage industry is awash in deceptive marketing, green washing and poor environmental stewardship.
In my most recent blog, I cited a recent study by the non-profit organization, As You Sow, that rated 23 major beverage companies on a grade scale of an A-F, depending on a few criteria of environmentally-friendliness.
Coca-Cola got the highest grade with a low C--and it quickly went downward from there. Some companies cited were Nestle, Pepsi, Snapple, Anheuser Busch and others.
You can read about that mind-numbing study at my post at: http://greenspotblog.com/?p=279
Let's eliminate single serve containers, encourage reusable water bottles and use water filters for tap.
Here's to a greener tomorrow, today.
------------------------------
Robert Piller is President of EcoMarketingSolutions.com, which helps companies promote their brand and image at trade shows and in direct mail with environmentally-friendly imprinted promotional products that won't end up in landfills. He is a frequent guest columnist and speaker and his blog is at greenspotblog.com.
Clean coal companies
I agree with this article as fiji water takes out for green campaign and apart from this clean coal have come up.This may generalize some of environmental issues.
Greenwashing
The Greenwash concept is really horrible. Releasing an ad that is designed to give a green image while the company is not sustainable to the environment at all...I am so glad that people are revealing them for what they are in lists like this.
I do think that we need to continue to focus on the companies that are fighting for the green movement. I recently wrote this post: http://greenertrends.com/2008/12/30/green-semi-trucks/ which is about how Hydrogen power can now fuel a semi truck. This company along with the others our there in this green movement need to be celebrated as much as the companies that are being greenwashed should be revealed for expecting people to fall for their deceiving advertisements.
Thank you for the great post!
-Kate
The Paradoxical Phrase "clean coal"
I am glad to see not all is falling for the shameless ACCCE spin campaign to paint coal as clean!! I still can't get how they convinced the presidential candidates to get on board!!! Well here is a blog I found, it called the use of the "clean coal" phrase is TRAVESTY and rightly so: http://www.ethanolplug.com/PlugBlog/tabid/60/EntryId/5/-font-size-2-What...
Marketplace
Marketplace is actually produced by American Public Media, not NPR.
Subaru
I saw an ad for Subaru claiming to produce cars in a Zero Landfill plant. Any comments?
Post new comment